Glock 17 vs Sig P226: How Do These Models Compare?

If you’re looking for a tried and tested high-capacity pistol for self-defense, it’s no wonder you’ve narrowed it down to the Glock 17 and the Sig Sauer P226. Both of these models have been proven to be functional, high-quality weapons trusted by the military, law enforcement, and civilians alike. 

When comparing the Sig P226 vs Glock 17, it’s clear they are very different pistols. While the standard-sized G17 features Glock’s Safe Action trigger system, the full-size P226 operates with a double-action/single-action trigger and features an accessory rail. The Glock also has a slightly larger capacity at 17 rounds compared to the P226’s 15. 

In this article, we’ll talk about why these pistols are so popular and break down the differences between the two to help you determine which is better suited to your needs. 

Glock 17

Highly trusted by military and law enforcement personnel around the world, the Glock 17 has a reputation for superior reliability and high capacity with minimal bulk and weight. It has all the markers of an excellent self-defense weapon, and, like all Glocks, can easily be customized to your preferences. 

The G17 features Glock’s Safe Action trigger system, making it a safe, fast, and user-friendly option. Built with a high-strength nylon-based polymer, this durable firearm is also chambered in 9mm and boasts an impressive 17-round capacity with aftermarket options of up to 30 rounds. 

Although it’s considered a standard-sized pistol, the Glock 17 is lightweight enough to be comfortable during everyday carry yet large enough to comfortably grip and shoot. 

If you’re looking for a Glock 17 holster, check out our selection of Kydex IWB, OWB, and pocket carry holsters.

Sig Sauer P226

The Sig Sauer P226 has been trusted by everyone from Navy SEALs, federal agents, and other law enforcement officers throughout the years, and for good reason. The P226 is known for being incredibly reliable and accurate.

Sig Sauer offers many variations of the P226, but for the purposes of this article, we’ll look at the base model: the P226 Nitron. As we go, just keep in mind that if you’re not seeing the features you want, there’s a good chance they’re available in another variation. You can check out the entire P226 series here. 

The P226 Nitron is chambered in 9mm and comes standard with a 15+1 round magazine. It features a double/single-action (DA/SA) pistol, meaning the first shot is long and heavy, while each subsequent shot is short and crisp.

If you’re looking for a Sig Sauer P226 holster, check out our selection of Kydex IWB, OWB, and pocket carry holsters.

Glock 17 vs Sig P226: Specs

Sig Sauer P226 vs Glock 17: Size & Capacity

The Glock 17 vs Sig P226 size comparison is very similar. The G17 is considered a standard-sized pistol yet is highly comparable to the full-sized P226. The Glock 17 weighs 32.28 ounces and stands 5.47 inches tall, 1.26 inches wide, and 8.03 inches long with a barrel length of 4.49 inches. The Sig P226 Nitron, on the other hand, weighs 34 ounces and measures 5.5 inches tall, 1.5 inches wide, and 7.7 inches long with a barrel length of 4.4 inches. 

Both pistols are chambered in 9mm though the Glock has a higher round capacity at 17+1 vs the P226’s 15+1. However, extended magazines are available for both models if you’re looking for a little boost. 

Glock 17 vs Sig P226: Frame, Slide & Barrel

The Sig P226 Nitron is built with a carbon steel barrel and stainless steel slide with rear slide serrations. It also comes with an accessory rail for adding lights and lasers to your pistol. 

The Glock 17 is equipped with Glock’s Marksman Barrel, which has enhanced rifling for improved accuracy. It’s made of high-strength nylon-based polymer and comes with interchangeable backstraps so you can customize it to your hand size. The G17 does not come out of the box with an accessory rail, but the good news is you can buy one aftermarket if this is important to you. 

Glock 17 vs Sig P226: Sights & Optics

While the Glock 17 comes with the manufacturer’s standard plastic sights, the Sig P226 Nitron is built with Sig’s SIGLITE Night sights, which are excellent in low-light conditions. 

Neither base model comes optics-ready, but if that’s a dealbreaker for you, don’t worry. You’ve got options. The MOS version of the Glock 17 does come optics-ready, and aftermarket slides with optics-compatibility are also available for the P226.

Sig Sauer P226 vs Glock 17: Controls

Trigger

The Sig P226 has a double/single-action trigger, which means it has a long, hard first pull with short, crisp subsequent shots. Its double-action pull is just over 8 pounds while its single-action pull is around 4 pounds. 

The G17, on the other hand, has Glock’s Safe Action trigger system with a pull weight of 6.3 pounds.

Safety

Neither pistol comes with a manual safety, but both have other safety features to prevent negligent discharges. 

The Glock 17’s Safe Action trigger system is also its safety feature, and is made up of three independent mechanical safeties that disengage as the trigger is pulled and re-engage as it is released, also providing drop safety.

Alternatively, the P226 features a striker block, a magazine release, slide release, and a decocking lever for easy use and takedown.

FAQ: Glock 17 vs Sig P226

Can You Conceal Carry a Glock 17?

Although most people find it easier to conceal compact guns or smaller, a standard-sized pistol like the Glock 17 can also work well for everyday carry with proper gear. 

Selecting the right Glock 17 holster, carry position, and clothing can ensure a comfortable, print-free carry experience. A sturdy gun belt that can support the weight of your rig can also go a long way in making sure your gun is concealable for long periods. 

Can You Conceal Carry a Sig P226?

Similarly, the Sig Sauer P226, although a full-sized pistol, can still be comfortably concealed carried with the right gear and strategy. Choosing a sturdy gun belt will support the weight of your setup and a quality Kydex holster, along with a carry position that works for you, will keep your rig comfortable for long periods. Because it is such a large pistol, it will be extra important to strategically choose clothing that reduces printing. 

Do SEALs Still Carry The P226?

No. According to The National Interest, although Navy SEALs used the Sig Sauer P226 for about three decades, they made the switch to the Glock 19 in 2015. The decision was made not because the P226 was inferior, but rather because the cost of the Glock 19 was less, and it became a more practical option. 

Which is Right For Me?

It’s hard to definitely say that one pistol is better than the other when comparing the Sig P226 vs Glock 17. Although they are very different from each other, they are both high-quality, reliable pistols that have been trusted by military, law enforcement, and civilians for decades. 

If you’re looking for a double/single action trigger, the Sig P226 will be a better fit than the G17, which features Glock’s Safe Action trigger system. The P226 is also a better option if you’re looking for the ability to mount lights and lasers out of the box, as it comes with a rail. The Glock will be a better choice if you want a higher capacity, as it comes standard with two more rounds than the P226 with extended magazines of up to 30+1. 

No matter which you choose, you can rest assured it will be a highly functional pistol that gives you peace of mind when used for self-defense. The best one for you will come down to personal needs and preferences.  

Looking for a reliable, custom-fit holster? Visit our Holsters by Gun Model page to find Kydex holsters tailored to your firearm. Plus, explore our Resources Page for gear recommendations, concealed carry guides, and exclusive content to elevate your carry system. 

*This page contains affiliate links. When you purchase a product included on this list, we receive a commission at no extra cost to you.